US Cities With the Worst Tap Water Records: EPA Violations, PFAS, Lead

Water systems with EPA health-limit violations, the highest PFOA/PFOS, and the highest lead, from EPA records with dates, plus the hardest utility-reported water.

Short answer

In EPA's October 2026 data, 24 of the water systems we track had a health-limit violation since November 2023, 157 had PFOA or PFOS above EPA's 4 ppt standard in UCMR 5 testing, and 3 had lead above the current 15 ppb action level. The lists below name them, with dates.

"Worst water" lists usually rank cities by reputation or by a single number. We use the public records instead, and we keep the problems separate, because a health-limit violation, a PFAS detection, high lead, and hard water are very different things. Every city below links to its full report with sources and dates.

How we built these lists

  • Violations: health-based violations reported to EPA (exceeding a contaminant limit or missing a required treatment step) for compliance periods starting November 2023 or later, from EPA's October 14, 2026 data export. Many have since been resolved; each city report shows the status.
  • PFOA and PFOS: the highest average at any single entry point in EPA's final UCMR 5 testing (2023 to 2025). EPA's 4 ppt limits become enforceable in 2029.
  • Lead: the latest 90th-percentile result from the last six years. Lead mostly comes from home plumbing, so these numbers describe risk across the system, not every tap.
  • Hardness: only cities where the utility's own 2025 report gives a hardness figure. Hardness is not a health issue.

EPA health-limit violations since November 2023

Water systems with a violation of a contaminant or disinfectant limit, most violations first. Check each report for whether it has been resolved.

CityViolationsContaminants
Springfield, MA10Total Haloacetic Acids (HAA5)
Jackson, MS7Total Haloacetic Acids (HAA5), TTHM, Lead and Copper Rule
Valdosta, GA7Total Haloacetic Acids (HAA5), TTHM
Shreveport, LA4Interim Enhanced Surface Water Treatment Rule, TTHM, Surface Water Treatment Rule
Lauderhill, FL4TTHM
Pflugerville, TX3TTHM
Perth Amboy, NJ3Gross Alpha, Excl. Radon and U
Baltimore, MD2TTHM
Laredo, TX2Revised Total Coliform Rule, Lead and Copper Rule Revisions
San Angelo, TX2TTHM
Grand Island, NE2Combined Uranium
Columbia, SC1Chlorite
Akron, OH1Total Haloacetic Acids (HAA5)
Trenton, NJ1TTHM
Georgetown, TX1TTHM
Lancaster, PA1TTHM
Edinburg, TX1TTHM
Maricopa, AZ1Revised Total Coliform Rule
San Marcos, TX1TTHM
Kannapolis, NC1Revised Total Coliform Rule

Highest PFOA/PFOS in EPA testing

Highest single entry-point average for PFOA or PFOS in UCMR 5 (2023 to 2025). EPA's limit is 4 ppt for each, enforceable from 2029.

CityPFOAPFOS
Tempe, AZ38 ppt55 ppt
Oxford, MS4.4 ppt53 ppt
Augusta, GA27 ppt44 ppt
Sacramento, CA16 ppt39 ppt
Ocala, FL6.5 ppt39 ppt
Downey, CA13 ppt38 ppt
Lauderhill, FL10 ppt35 ppt
Miami, FL12 ppt31 ppt
Anaheim, CA10 ppt29 ppt
Pembroke Pines, FL12 ppt29 ppt
Parkersburg, WV29 pptND
Greensboro, NC3.7 ppt27 ppt
Hialeah, FL9 ppt26 ppt
Coconut Creek, FL10 ppt26 ppt
Abilene, TX6.9 ppt25 ppt
Boynton Beach, FL8.5 ppt25 ppt
Margate, FL6 ppt25 ppt
Pensacola, FL16 ppt24 ppt
South Gate, CA9.1 ppt24 ppt
Newark, DE23 ppt7.4 ppt

Highest lead results

Latest 90th-percentile lead above 10 ppb (EPA's action level is 15 ppb now and 10 ppb from November 2027).

CityLead (90th pct.)Testing period
Troy, NY110 ppbJan 2026–Jun 2026
Quincy, MA21 ppbJan 2026–Dec 2026
Elgin, IL18.5 ppbJan 2026–Jun 2026
Cheyenne, WY15 ppbJan 2025–Dec 2025
Minot, ND13.5 ppbJan 2022–Dec 2024
Albany, NY13 ppbJul 2025–Dec 2025
DeKalb, IL13 ppbJan 2026–Jun 2026
Omaha, NE12.3 ppbJan 2023–Dec 2025
New Rochelle, NY12.2 ppbJan 2025–Dec 2027
Modesto, CA12 ppbJan 2025–Dec 2027
Syracuse, NY12 ppbJul 2025–Dec 2025
Great Falls, MT12 ppbJan 2026–Jun 2026
Fall River, MA12 ppbJan 2025–Dec 2025
Peoria, IL11 ppbJan 2026–Jun 2026
Olathe, KS11 ppbJan 2021–Dec 2023
Hattiesburg, MS10.4 ppbJan 2021–Dec 2023
Garden City, NY10.2 ppbJan 2026–Jun 2026

Hardest water (utility-reported)

Cities where the utility's 2025 report gives hardness of 180 PPM or more. Hardness causes scale but is not a health issue.

CityHardness
Indianapolis, IN148–460 PPM (varies by area)
Las Vegas, NV280 PPM
Phoenix, AZ172–302 PPM (varies by area)
Camp Hill, PA68–296 PPM (varies by area)

What to do if your city is on a list

Read your city's report first: it shows whether a violation is resolved and when testing happened. For lead or PFOA/PFOS, a filter certified for that contaminant reduces what you drink; see our certified filter comparison. For hard water, see softener vs. filter. Your utility's annual Consumer Confidence Report has the full list of contaminants it tests for.

💧 Not Sure What You Need?

Take our 60-second quiz to narrow down the right system for your situation.

Take the Water Quiz →
💧

What Does Your Water Need?

60-second quiz to narrow down your options.

Take the Quiz

Check Your Water

See your city's data.

Look up your city

Quick Test

Screen for 17 contaminants at home in 2 minutes.

Varify 17-in-1 Test Strips →

Affiliate link

Compare Systems

Side-by-side comparisons